Jan, 2020 retired pope benedict has issued a passionate defense of priestly celibacy, saying he cannot remain silent as his successor pope francis considers easing the prohibition on married men serving. The contentious relationship between pope francis and pope. Fake news treatment of pope benedict letter about francis. The secret papers of benedict xvi consisting of confidential letters and memos between pope benedict and his personal secretary, a controversial book that portrays the vatican as a hotbed of jealousy, intrigue and underhanded factional fighting. Benedict xvi has asked cardinal sarah to have his name removed from the book on priestly celibacy. Amid benedict book controversy, vatican officials see need for rules. Jan 14, 2020 the former pope benedict xvi has requested the removal of his name as the coauthor of a controversial new book in which he spoke out against allowing married men to become priests as a dispute. Former pope benedict wants name removed from controversial. Celibacy book coauthored by former pop e benedict stirs controversy at the vatican a new book about celibacy and the catholic church has set off a firestorm at the vatican as pope francis.
Drama over benedict xvis coauthored book about priestly. Jan 15, 2020 americas vatican correspondent explains benedicts book controversy inside the vatican january 15, 2020 pope francis visits his predecessor, retired pope benedict xvi, at the mater ecclesiae. Expope benedict xvi links gay marriage, abortion with the. Pope benedict demands his name is taken off controversial new. Benedict removes name from book on celibacy after dispute. Sales of novel on benedicts murder soar ahead of popes. Cnn retired pope benedict xvi said he did not coauthor a book seen as undercutting his successor pope francis, according to his private secretary, georg gaenswein. The book is coauthored by guinean cardinal robert sarah, prefect of the congregation for divine worship, and pope emeritus benedict xvi, with the cover of the book prominently displaying photos of both men. Expope benedict seeks to end storm over controversial book. Celibacy book coauthored by former pope benedict stirs controversy at the vatican. Retired pope benedicts book addresses priestly celibacy. A cat recounts the life of pope benedict xvi was published in 2007 which told the story of the pope s life from the feline chicos perspective. Canadian author daniel gawthrop, in a critical biography, the trial of pope benedict, said that the pope blamed homosexuality for a problem the church had willingly enabled for hundreds of years.
Retired pope distances himself from book seen as undercutting. Former pope benedict wants his name removed as coauthor of a new book about priestly celibacy, days after excerpts were published, in the latest twist in a saga that has riveted the roman. Retired pope breaks promise to hide from the world. The issue exploded this week amid controversy around a book the publishers say was coauthored by benedict and cardinal robert sarah, a leading vatican conservative, on the issue of priestly. Pope benedict demands his name is taken off controversial. Celibacy book coauthored by former pope benedict stirs. Jan 16, 2020 others wondered if the ex pope really contributed to the book, or if the 92yearold who retired for health reasons in 20 was being exploited by people with an interest in undercutting francis. Jan 16, 2020 initial prepublication publicity for the book provoked controversy, because it seemed to set benedict in opposition to pope francis who is reportedly considering a proposal to permit the ordination of older married men in certain circumstances. Jan 17, 2020 the issue exploded this week amid controversy around a book the publishers say was coauthored by pope benedict and cardinal robert sarah, a leading vatican conservative, on the issue of priestly celibacy. Pope benedict orders his name be removed from controversial. Gabriele was sentenced to 18 months in an italian prison. Pope benedicts name removed from controversial celibacy. This story was inspired by an orange tabby pentling cat, which belonged to the family next door.
Jan, 2020 retired pope benedict xvi, who promised to remain silent when he resigned as head of the roman catholic church seven years ago, has stepped back into the ongoing debate over priestly celibacy with. Jan 14, 2020 vatican city retired pope benedict xvis name is being removed as a coauthor of a controversial new book defending the catholic churchs practice of clerical celibacy after dueling accounts. Benedict xvi wants his name removed from book about. Whether his newest tome will be as well depends on the type of catholic you are and where you fall on the doctrinal spectrum.
The book is coauthored by guinean cardinal robert sarah, prefect of the congregation for divine worship, and pope emeritus benedict xvi, with. Jan 14, 2020 pope emeritus benedict xvis longtime aide is pushing to have the retired pontiff removed as coauthor of a controversial book on. Senior official sources said they hope pope francis addresses the issue after the death of benedict, who in 20 became the first pope in 700 years to abdicate and who is now a frail 92yearold. Learn about the early life of pope benedict xvi and his involvement in.
Retired pope benedict distances himself from controversial. Benedict caused a stir last year with an essay in which he blamed the churchs sexual abuse scandal on the effects of the sexual revolution in the 1960s. Church law says a pope can resign, but it lacks specific rules on his status, title, and prerogatives. Expope benedict asks to be removed as coauthor of book in. Pope benedict no longer listed as coauthor of new book the retired pontiff faced criticism that his writings on priestly celibacy would undermine the incumbent pope. In his own words xvi, pope benedict, seewald, peter on.
Americas vatican correspondent explains benedicts book controversy. Jan 14, 2020 pope emeritus benedict xvi is distancing himself from a controversial new book about the importance of priestly celibacy that he was listed as the coauthor of in what critics argued undermined pope francis. The scandal escalated in may 2012 when nuzzi published a book entitled his holiness. The vatican leaks scandal, also known as vatileaks, is a scandal initially involving leaked. Vatican seeks to explain absence of aide after book scandal abc. Two popes one retired, one reigning cause a furor abc. Pope benedicts name removed from controversial celibacy book. Jan 14, 2020 retired pope benedict xvi has broken his silence to reaffirm the value of priestly celibacy, coauthoring a bombshell book at the precise moment that pope francis is weighing whether to allow married men to be ordained to address the catholic priest shortage. May 04, 2020 benedict xvi is stirring up new controversy. Feb 22, 2021 cornwells past books including the controversial hitlers pope about pius xii and pontiff in winter about john paul ii have been bestsellers. Former pope benedict wants his name removed as coauthor of a controversial book on the issue of priestly celibacy, his. Jan, 2020 pope opens amazon summit amid controversy over proposal to allow married priests excerpts of the book indicate that the 92yearold benedict, and sarah, a fellow conservative, wrote separate. Vatican city reuters former pope benedict wants his name removed as coauthor of a new book on the issue of priestly celibacy, his personal secretary said on tuesday, in the latest twist to a.
Retired pope benedict xvi sought to distance himself from an upcoming book that deals with the issue of priestly celibacy and asked that he no. Benedict xvi wants his name removed from book about priestly. The catholic press is releasing from the depths of our hearts by retired pope benedict xvi and cardinal robert sarah amid controversy over. Benedict xvi and cardinal sarah coauthor book on celibacy, opposing the ordination of married men. On the eve of publication, pope benedict said he wanted his name removed as coauthor. The two popes rivalry explodes into public with dispute over.
The controversy over the cardinal robert sarahemeritus pope benedict xvi book on priestly celibacy, and the chaos surrounding its publication. Vatican city the vatican sought wednesday to explain the absence of a key member of pope francis protocol team following his role in a. Since leaving his position as pope due to health concerns in 20, benedict has drawn criticism for sometimes appearing to undermine his successor. In new book, retired pope benedict breaks silence to speak. Robert sarah, from the depths of our hearts, has caused an earthquake even before it has been published, as well as an unhinged and. Controversy erupted this week when reports emerged that benedict, who retired in 20, coauthored a book defending celibacy as a necessity. Jan 21, 2020 on january 16, eugenio scalfari meets with pope francis, asking him about the controversy surrounding the new book.
A new book about celibacy and the catholic church has set. Americas vatican correspondent explains benedicts book. Priesthood, celibacy and the crisis of the catholic church, has been viewed as an attempt to. Expope benedict asks to be removed as coauthor of book. The book, from the depths of our hearts, puts up a staunch defence of celibacy and was interpreted as a critical attack on pope francis, who is. Jan 24, 2020 pope emeritus benedict, by all accounts aged and ailing, was dragged into a controversy last week over his alleged coauthorship of a book defending priestly celibacy. The book, titled from the depths of our hearts, argues in favor of the centuries old tradition of priestly celibacy within the church, defending the. Priesthood, celibacy, and the crisis of the catholic church, was recently announced, and controversy started almost immediately. Pope benedict no longer listed as coauthor of new book.
The former pope benedict xvi has requested the removal of his name as the coauthor of a controversial new book in which he spoke out. In tempest over benedict xvi and book on celibacy, it is as. Jan 15, 2020 celibacy book coauthored by former pop e benedict stirs controversy at the vatican a new book about celibacy and the catholic church has set off a firestorm at the vatican as pope francis. Jan 14, 2020 a battle inside the vatican over a book about priestly celibacy took an odd turn on tuesday when pope benedict demanded his name be taken off it, a day before it was due to appear in bookshops.
Former pope benedict wants his name removed from new book. Pope francis favored interviewer casts cdl sarah as leading. Retired pope benedict xvi has broken his silence to reaffirm the value of priestly celibacy, coauthoring a bombshell book at the precise moment that pope francis is weighing whether. Former pope benedict wants his name removed as coauthor of a controversial book on the issue of priestly celibacy, his personal secretary. Much controversy still surrounds pope benedict s papacyin this book he addresses these controversies and reveals how at his late age, governing and reforming the papacy and. Jan 14, 2020 cnn retired pope benedict xvi said he did not coauthor a book seen as undercutting his successor pope francis, according to his private secretary, georg gaenswein. Pope benedict no longer listed as coauthor of new book nbc news. On a more personal level he writes with great warmth of his successor pope francis, who he admits has a popular touch, a star quality which benedict himself has lacked.
Pope benedict wants his name removed as coauthor of. Expope benedict wants name removed from controversial. Pope benedict speaks out in favor of celibacy for priests cnn. Feb 11, 20 the year 2012 brought the vatileaks scandal in which benedict s former butler paolo gabriele was convicted of stealing the pope s private papers from his apartments and leaking them to a journalist, who published them in a bestselling book. Oct 25, 2019 the vatican official behind the lettergate controversy, which involved doctoring a photo, made a mess and caused problems, according to abp. Jan 15, 2020 the new book written by pope emeritus benedict xvi and cdl. Sales of a controversial turkish novel about a conspiracy to kill pope benedict xvi are soaring ahead of the pontiffs historic. Jan 14, 2020 pope benedict no longer listed as coauthor of new book the retired pontiff faced criticism that his writings on priestly celibacy would undermine the incumbent pope. The book, titled from the depths of our hearts, argues in favor of the centuriesold tradition of priestly celibacy within the church, defending the. The controversy over the new book on priestly celibacy by cardinal robert sarah and pope emeritus benedict xvi has only continued to escalate over the past 48 hours. Pope benedict xvi speaks at the vatican february 27, 20. Pope francis visits his predecessor, retired pope benedict xvi, at the mater ecclesiae monastery at the vatican in this dec. Pope benedicts celibacy views complicate catholic church.
Expope benedict wants name removed from controversial book aide. New book church, interrupted heralds pope francis as agent. The controversy began when gerard oconnell, vatican correspondent for america magazine tweeted. Pope benedict orders his name be removed from controversial book. The two popes rivalry explodes into public with dispute. Jan 17, 2020 pope emeritus benedict xvis contributions have been the subject of controversy since the book was announced on sunday, and conflicting statements on the extent of the pope emerituss. Former pope benedict has asked for his name to be removed as the coauthor of a controversial new book that threatened to undermine his successor over the highly sensitive issue of celibacy.
Pope opens amazon summit amid controversy over proposal to allow married priests. Mar 17, 2018 the vatican has finally released the full text of the letter of pope emeritus benedict xvi following a fiveday long public controversy in which the secretariat for communications was accused of. Publisher speaks out on benedict xvi book controversy. Much controversy still surrounds pope benedict s papacyin this book he addresses these controversies and reveals how at his late age, governing and reforming the papacy and particularly the vatican, was beyond him.
Ignatius plans no changes in book coauthored by pope benedict. Senior official sources said they hope pope francis addresses the issue after the death of benedict, who in 20 became the first pope in 700 years to abdicate and who is now a frail 92year. Pope benedict wants his name removed as coauthor of controversial new book about celibacy. Claims pope emeritus didnt coauthor new book on celibacy. Pope opens amazon summit amid controversy over proposal to allow married priests excerpts of the book indicate that the 92yearold benedict, and sarah, a fellow conservative, wrote separate. Benedict defends priestly celibacy as pope francis considers. News of the book broke on sunday, and by monday afternoon, rumors had begun percolating on social media that benedict had not, in fact, coauthored the book. Retired pope to be removed as celibacy book author bbc news. Pope benedict speaks out in favor of celibacy for priests. An imbroglio over former pope benedict s involvement in a book has sparked calls by some vatican officials for clear rules about the status of any future pontiffs who may resign rather than rule for life. After benedict s show of solidarity with pope francis, the issue with.
According to his aide, the former pope never intended to have his name on the book parts. Jan 14, 2020 the cardinal who cowrote a book backing priestly celibacy with the retired pope has said benedict xvis name will be removed from future editions. Following controversy, vatican publishes full text of. Jan 15, 2020 the current fracas surrounding benedict xvi and a new book on priestly celibacy is eerily reminiscent of the tempest that erupted in 20032004 around st. Jan 12, 2020 benedict s remarks, revealed in a new book excerpt published sunday by the french newspaper le figaro, cast light on a onceunthinkable dynamic inside the roman catholic church. In new book, retired pope benedict breaks silence to speak out. Jan 14, 2020 in light of the controversy surrounding the excerpt, benedict has walked back his involvement in the book. Amid benedict book controversy, vatican officials see need. Retired former pope benedict xvi sought to calm a dispute within the vatican on tuesday, claiming his name was erroneously attributed as coauthor to a new book with a conservative cardinal. The former pope benedict xvi has requested the removal of his name as the co author of a controversial new book in which he spoke out. The vatican tried to downplay the controversy, issuing a statement that francis, too, has upheld the rule of priestly celibacy and that benedict s book is a mere contribution written in. Amid pope benedict book controversy, vatican officials see.
117 1563 1173 133 812 121 1551 147 951 1331 250 1307 1507 307 1504 227 378 102 125 174 259 775 507